The $5.2M Aaron Judge Superfractor Sale + Philly Show Buying Frenzy + Was Breaking Up the 1966 Topps Set the Right Move?

In this episode, Jeremy Lee is joined by Leighton Sheldon and David Chase for a conversation that moves from vintage hockey to a red hot show floor and then into one of the biggest modern card sales in hobby history. The episode opens with more discussion around the decision to break up a high grade 1966 Topps Hockey set card by card rather than sell it as a complete set. Along the way, the conversation branches into Bobby Orr versus Gordie Howe, hobby Mount Rushmore talk, vintage hockey card aesthetics, and what makes certain iconic cards feel larger than the players themselves. From there, Leighton shares a detailed report from the Philadelphia show, where the crowd, dealer activity, and overall momentum all pointed to a hobby that feels extremely strong right now. He talks about the competitive nature of buying on the floor, the challenge of acquiring great material even when you are ready to spend, and a standout pickup from the weekend: a 1949 Bowman Jackie Robinson that checked the eye appeal box in a big way. The conversation then shifts to the $5.2 million Aaron Judge Superfractor 1/1 sale, a result that made mainstream headlines well beyond the hobby. Jeremy, Leighton, and David discuss what a sale like that says about the state of the market, whether it signals strength or excess, and why media attention around major card sales continues to bring more awareness and energy into the space. If you enjoy hobby talk that blends vintage perspective, market insight, and real conversations from inside the show floor, please follow the podcast, leave a rating or review, and share this episode with a fellow collector. Be sure to check out Jeremy’s new book Pops and Comps and take the Hobby Spectrum assessment to discover your collector identity and connect with others in the directory. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices